Welcome to Reliberation Sign in | Help
in
Latest Most Popular Active Watch List Amigos  
Cathy Clark

Cape Cod Real Estate

Assessed Value vs. List Price

By: Cathy Clark
Thursday, July 05, 2007 12:23 PM

I don't know about your areas, by our Assessed Values as compared to List Price/Market Values are soooo skewed!

For example, a home assessed at $1.2MM sold for $950K.  An almost identical home, assessed at $1.1MM, sold for $1.5MM.  Not my listings, unfortunately.  However, I find that because of the spike in home sale prices over the past few years, assessments have, naturally falsely increased. I don't know that "falsely" is the word I'm looking for, but can't presently come up with a better word.

Now, though, prices have fallen. Or have they risen, based on the above example?  My own home is assessed at $399K,(up from $250K four years ago),  yet I know for a fact that I couldn't get $325K for it from a cash Buyer with no appraisal!  The only improvement on the house in the last 40 years is a brand, spankin' new septic system.  Needs a new roof, windows, trim (termites. Gotta love them woodpeckers.  I'm hoping they get all those "termy's), basement floods if the sump pump dies, etc.) It doesn't even have an automatic garage door opener! All because other homes in my 'hood have sold for over $600K,  none under $500K.  My property taxes seem to be increasing exponentially.  Yeah, I'm going for the abatement.  That's another story.  Moving right along.

My point is.....(about time, huh?).....Are your Assessments vs. Market Values as skewed as mine?  And how do you explain that to a Buyer who sees an assessment of, for argument's sake, 400K vs. an asking price of $520K?  Conversely, how do you explain a list price of say, $550K vs. an assessed value of $650K (the first question is "What's wrong with it?). 

My present explanation is that the Assessment is based on a state formula and the specific Town's needs for revenue.  While the assessment can go up, the tax rate can go down, and result in either an increase in property tax, or a decrease.  I've been doing my research on this and have no real and understandable explanation!  Despite the internet, it's almost impossible to get an understandable explanation of how municipalities arrive at assessments and property taxes.  Just try deciphering the Department of Revenues rules and regs. And still.......Absolutely none of this (assessments)  has any effect on fair market value of a home!  The only factor that applies is what a Buyer is willing to pay for a particular property!

I've thought about printing the "bare bones" listing sheets that don't include assessed values, but I just believe that's wrong and I have to be able to explain why a property is appropriately priced, overpriced or underpriced.  It's all public knowledge anywya. Mind you, our Assessors do not visit homes to see their "state of repair".  Improvements or lack thereof.  They use building permits to determine significant home improvements that will increase the value of a home.  And, of course, they use Registry Records.

I don't blame the Towns for the skewed assessments.  They have very few staff and cannot visit homes.  They're doing the best they can with what information they have available to them over the internet.  Much like Z****w dot com, which is also skewed for the same reasons.

Have I rambled and spewed enough?  Think so.  Thanks for listening and if anyone has any suggestions on how you handle this, I would be most grateful!

 

 

<< Read More at Reliberation.com

Comments

Jay & Francy Thompson  REALTORS®
Member Since '05

Jay & Francy Thompson REALTORS® said:

Ours are completely out of whack with reality. Part of that is due to the astronomical appreciation rates we realized over the past couple of years. Part of it is due to the fact that the county assessors can't possibly keep up with all the new construction. And part of it's likely due to general goverment / bureaucratic ineptitude.

July 5, 2007 12:05 PM
Lew Corcoran
Member Since '03

Lew Corcoran said:

When you had a hot real estate market like we had in between 2000 and 2005, values and assessments are bound to get out of whack.

Here in these neck of the woods, we're going through a reassessment. This happens about once every so often to get property assessments back in line or nearly so.  

July 5, 2007 12:09 PM
The C Team
Member Since '04

The C Team said:

Utah is a non-disclosure state, which means we don't have to tell the County what was paid for the home, lot, etc.  That being said, I know that in Iron County, they have access to the MLS.  We were reassessed in 06 based on what had been happening, but I doubt they will reassess us lower.  

When I started in RE, assessed value was about 80% of what a home would sell for - now I couldn't even begin to explain it.  My own home is probably assessed at 90% of what I could sell it for (with repairs made - I also have a long list Cathy) to a cash buyer.  I know for a fact that my parents were assessed at more than they paid for lots and current lots are selling below assessed value in that particular subdivision.

I usually explain to Buyers/Sellers, that we are a non-disclosure state and that the assessment is not an appraisal. I usually use the assessment as a guide to price a home no lower than.

July 5, 2007 12:49 PM
Belinda Walker
Member Since '06

Belinda Walker said:

Our assessments vs. prive are skewed here, too, but in the opposite directions.  Most homes here sell for an average of 1.25 of assessed value.

July 5, 2007 2:29 PM
Joe Schutt
Member Since '06

Joe Schutt said:

Most of our assessed values are lower than market as well. I tell buyers that they should be grateful because they are paying taxes on the lower (assessed) value.

I was also told by someone, don't know how true, that they assess them on the low side so if eminent domain comes into play they go by the assessed value of the property - not market value.

In an area like Massachusetts I could see this being the case versus a much larger state because we don't have much land left to build on.

July 6, 2007 7:49 AM
Radley Reiff
Member Since '04

Radley Reiff said:

In Atlanta, assessed values seem to fall around 80-90% of market value.  If assess values were higher than market value, then everybody would run get an appeal and clog up the tax office.  However, Atlanta may be a little fortunate because we are a very stable and balanced market.

- Radley / Atlanta

July 6, 2007 7:54 AM
Gail Griffin
Member Since '03

Gail Griffin said:

Here in California, we have the infamous Proposition 13 that was passed by the voters in 1978. This law limits the property tax to 1% of a home's assessed value and the assessed value cannot increase more than 2% per year until the property is resold. Thus, market value and assessed value are rarely compared.

July 6, 2007 9:49 AM

Add a comment

To post a comment you can sign in using a Point2 ID. Sign in.
Don't have a Point2 ID? Join Point2 NLS or post as a guest.

My Blog

Cathy Clark
Rivet Realty Group

Cathy  Clark
Member Since '06

recent comments
"can someone illuminate me p..."
Cathy Clark
"mls opportunity lost"
Cathy Clark
"pools foreclosure serious h..."
Cathy Clark
"it goes both ways no not ac..."
Cathy Clark
"political satire ahead"
Cathy Clark
"how are you handling the hi..."
Cathy Clark
"foreclosure in pawtucket"
Cathy Clark
"how are you handling the hi..."
Cathy Clark
"heads up"
Cathy Clark
"point2 and ebay"
Cathy Clark